The Original Buckeye Cake - click here

Topped with one dozen homemade buckeye candies, The Original Buckeye Cake is made to resemble Ohio’s favorite treat. Inside, you will find a perfect balance of deliciously creamy peanut butter and chocolate chip frosting set in between three moist layers of peanut butter cake. 

The Original Buckeye Cake is a proprietary recipe carefully prepared by Deb Messner, author of Cooking Ahead of Thyme & Thyme For Fresh. The cake is entirely original and homemade — from the cake batter to the frosting. Despite the fact that the cake takes hours to prepare, it is an affordable treat that will make any occasion more special. 72-hour advance notice required.